Here’s an argument that happens in golf bags everywhere: should you buy new golf balls or is used (refurbished, recycled, lake balls) just as good?
The honest answer is: it depends. Used balls can be an outstanding value or a complete waste of money — and the difference comes down to grade, source, and what you’re actually trying to accomplish. Let’s break it all down.
What Are Used Golf Balls, Exactly?
Used golf balls fall into a few categories:
- Recycled/used balls: Retrieved, cleaned, and sorted by condition. Sold as-is.
- Refurbished balls: Cleaned, repainted, and re-stamped. Often look new but may have hidden damage.
- Lake balls: Retrieved from water hazards. Quality varies wildly depending on how long they were submerged.
Understanding Used Ball Grades
Reputable used ball retailers grade their inventory. Here’s what the grades generally mean:
- AAAAA / Mint / 5A: Near perfect condition. Looks and performs like new. Often only played 1-3 holes before being lost.
- AAAA / 4A: Minor scuffs or slight discoloration. Performs very close to new.
- AAA / 3A: Visible wear marks. Some performance degradation, but still playable.
- AA / 2A and below: Significant wear, cuts, discoloration. Practice balls at best.
Buy AAAA or higher. Anything below that is best left for the practice range.
Does Water Damage Golf Balls?
Yes — and this is the key issue with lake balls. Research has shown that balls submerged in water for extended periods absorb moisture through the cover, which affects core performance. The longer the submersion, the worse the damage.
A ball in the water hazard for a few hours? Probably fine.
A ball sitting on the bottom of a pond for six months? The core is compromised.
This is why buying from reputable graded sellers matters. A 5A graded ball from a trusted source has been inspected and confirmed to be in genuine near-new condition. A mystery bucket of “lake finds” is a crapshoot.
New vs. Used: The Performance Comparison
New Golf Balls
Pros:
- Guaranteed performance as designed
- No hidden damage or core degradation
- Consistent condition across the box
- Looks great (if that matters to you)
Cons:
- More expensive, especially for premium balls
- Painful to lose in a hazard
Grade 5A Used Balls
Pros:
- Premium balls (Pro V1, TP5x, Chrome Soft) at 30-50% less
- Virtually indistinguishable performance from new
- Great for practice rounds or high-loss golfers
Cons:
- Quality depends entirely on the grader’s standards
- Mixed lots may have inconsistent performance
- Refurbished balls (repainted) can mask damage
When to Buy Used
- Practice rounds: Always. No reason to use new balls when you’re working on your game.
- High-handicap play: You’re losing balls anyway. Buy 5A used Pro V1s for half the price and play a better ball than you’d afford new.
- Trying a new ball: Buy a sleeve of used before committing to a full box of new.
When to Buy New
- Tournament play: Know exactly what you’re getting. Don’t risk a compromised ball in competition.
- Low handicappers who feel the difference: If you’re sensitive enough to notice subtle performance differences, buy new.
- When buying premium balls for the first time: Try them new first so you know what peak performance feels like.
Where to Buy Used Golf Balls
Stick to reputable retailers that use consistent grading systems. Look for sellers who clearly define their grades, offer returns, and have good reviews. Avoid unmarked buckets at garage sales or “lot listings” where you have no idea what you’re getting.
The Bottom Line
For most recreational golfers, 5A used balls are an excellent value — especially for premium brands you’d otherwise skip due to price. The performance difference between a mint used Pro V1 and a new one is negligible for the vast majority of players.
Buy new for competition. Buy 5A used for everything else. And skip the mystery lake ball buckets entirely.
Golf takes balls. It doesn’t require they be fresh out of the box.
Disclosure: This page contains affiliate links. If you buy through our links we earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Full disclosure here.